Cabbage Island–What’s Different, What’s the Same?

by Barb, working on the front porch in Boothbay Harbor, enjoying the scenery and the lovely breezes

I’ve been open about the fact that my Maine Clambake Mystery Series is “inspired by” the Cabbage Island Clambakes here in Boothbay Harbor. One of my fellow MCW writers Lea Wait’s daughter had her wedding reception there. Lea mentioned it to me in passing, and when my agent told me he was looking for a clambake-themed mystery series–bingo! An idea was born.

But, that idea was born in October, after the real Cabbage Island had closed down for the winter, and the series sold in February, so I wrote the first draft of Clammed Up without ever visiting Cabbage Island. I’ve always believed that was all to the good, because it left my imagination free to roam. I could make up an island, a family, and a “dining experience” that was unique. But in the name of research, my husband and I were the first people on the boat the following June when they reopened.

My husband, my daughter and I getting ready to board the Bennie Alice last weekend

My husband, my daughter and I getting ready to board the Bennie Alice

Now that the first three books are out, a handful of people have written me to say that inspired by the books, they came to Boothbay Harbor for vacation and have gone to the “real clambake.” Last weekend, which was the long July 4th weekend, my daughter-in-law requested for her birthday that the whole family, including her mom who was up visiting from Virginia, go out to the Cabbage Island Clambake.

In an interview, Hank Phillippi Ryan once asked me if I could ever attend a clambake again and not be working. I’m happy to report the answer is yes. We had a perfect day for the excursion, and I had a lovely, lovely time. I did pick up some island gossip and anecdotes which will probably make their way into a future book, but I was “hardly working.”

I thought, in the interest of setting expectations for potential visitors, I would point out some of the differences between my fictional Snowden Family Clambake and the real thing.

1) On the way to the clambake, you cruise on a former party boat which takes you on a harbor tour.

benniealice

The same. Also the same, the boats are named for the matriarch. In my books, the boat is the Jackie II, named for protagonist Julia Snowden’s mother, Jacqueline. The real boat is the Bennie Alice, named for 95-year-old Bennie Alice Moore, mother of the owners, who runs the island gift shop.

2) The clambakes are family-owned and run.

My family at the Cabbage Island Clambake

My family at the Cabbage Island Clambake

The same, though the families are entirely different. The Cabbage Island Clambakes are owned and run by brothers Wayne and Bob Moore. Four generations of Moores enjoy the island every summer. In the books, Julia Snowden has stepped up to run the Snowden Family Clambake Company along with her sister Livvie and brother-in-law Sonny Ramsey.

3) The island where the clambakes are held is just beyond the harbor mouth, in the Atlantic.

Not the same. Both Boothbay Harbor and the fictional Busman’s Harbor are vast with many islands, inhabited and uninhabited. But though the Snowden Family Clambake is just beyond the harbor mouth, Cabbage Island is inside the harbor in Linekin Bay.

linekin bay

4) There is an abandoned family mansion and a playhouse big enough to live in on the island.

Not the same. The Moores do have residences on Cabbage Island, but the island itself is less than half the size of my fictional Morrow Island. There’s no mansion, playhouse or beach, though there is a lovely lodge built in 1900. My brother is the only person who knows me well enough to have recognized the inspiration for the mansion and playhouse. It’s this little $27 million dollar beauty here, which was next door to my grandparents summer house in Water Mill, Long Island. (And by next door, I mean my grandparents’ modest ranch house was built on property that formerly belonged to the mansion grounds.) It did have a playhouse so complete it was rented out during the summer as a separate residence. The playhouse has been done over and expanded so many times over the years it’s no longer recognizable for what it once was. (On the other hand, the mansion in the books and the original inspiration look nothing alike. It’s just the idea.)

watermill

5) The meal consists of clam chowder, steamers, two lobsters, corn, a potato, an onion and an egg. Dessert is blueberry grunt.

cabbageislandluke

Almost the same. The Cabbage Island Clambake serves fish chowder and dessert is blueberry cake, but otherwise the meal is identical.

6) The meal is cooked in a pit, over rocks heated by a roaring wood fire and covered in seaweed and tarps.

Not quite the same. My description in Clammed Up is more “traditional”, but I have to admit I’ve wondered if it would be practical for serving that many people. The Cabbage Island set up includes all of those elements, but is on a raised structure.

clambakecooker

7) There is an island cat.

cabbageislandcat

The same. Though not a Maine coon like the Morrow Island cat, Le Roi.

cabbageislandosprey

There isn’t an osprey family on Morrow Island, but after seeing this one on Cabbage Island, I wonder if I need to add one in some future book?

The Moores, by the way, have been very gracious to me, answering questions and so on. When I told Bob on this trip that I’d only killed one person on the island, so far, he laughed and said, “As long as it isn’t me.”

About Barbara Ross

Barbara Ross is the author of the Maine Clambake Mysteries: Clammed Up, Boiled Over, Musseled Out, Fogged Inn and Iced Under. The sixth book, Stowed Away, will be published in December, 2017. You can visit her website at http://www.maineclambakemysteries.com.
This entry was posted in Barb's Posts and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to Cabbage Island–What’s Different, What’s the Same?

  1. Jewel Hanley says:

    Nicely done. I’ve been to Cabbage Island so recognized your inspirational location in your book. Maybe, the Moores and you should collaborate in a little join advertising in the Lincoln County News.

    Like

  2. Lea Wait says:

    Great post, Barb! I first went to a Cabbage Island Clambake when I was in college .. a Boothbay Playhouse colleague and I saved up (summer theatres don’t pay much) so we could go at the end of the summer. For many visitors to Boothbay Harbor it’s one of the “to do” places to go when on vacation. Loved the pictures of you and your family there!

    Like

  3. I love this, Barb. It’s so interesting to read about the similarities and differences!

    Like

  4. I’ve never been to the Cabbage Island Clambake, Barb, but you have whet my appetite. A few weeks ago we were visiting friends in Bayville whose house looks out on Cabbage Island–a lovely spot indeed.

    Like

  5. David Edgar Cournoyer says:

    Thanks for this Barbara. In addition to making me hungry enough to head north for a clam bake, you raise interesting questions about the relative proportions of research vs. imagination in creating a sense of place. In your work you seem to have struck a great balance, with enough authentic detail to make your settings feel real, but not enough to turn your stories into travel guides.

    Like

  6. Pingback: Authentic Enough? | Wicked Cozy Authors

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s