Being nosy has a bad wrap, even from the Merriam-Webster Dictionary, which says:

NOSY.
1. As in curious, interested in what is not one’s own business
2. As in busy, thrusting oneself where one is not welcome or invited

I’d like to present the positive side of being nosy. It’s really just
—Having curiosity
—Being observant
—Recognizing patterns
—Paying attention to what others miss

This isn’t meddling, it’s awareness, and in mystery writing, it’s practically a superpower. Writers have to be nosy.

We watch people in coffee shops. We eavesdrop in grocery lines. We take notes on ideas, problems, characterizations, gestures, and half-finished sentences. We’re collectors of human behavior, both the good and the bad.

We notice who hesitates before answering or who over-explains. Or who never makes eye contact, or who laughs a little too loudly.

We file it all away with the question, why are they behaving that way? These observations allow us to flesh out our characters and give them depth. Real people are layered: generous yet insecure, confident yet hiding something tender. I’m intrigued by the nuances that make us up, such as our pride, fear, regret, love, and jealousy.

One of my characters is always an amateur sleuth. And like many amateur sleuths, she is unapologetically nosy. This curious protagonist can:

— Overhear something that others ignore
— Look twice at what seems ordinary
— Ask uncomfortable or unexpected questions
— Bravely follow a hunch
— Act on instinct
— Connect minor details into a motive
— Sense when someone is protecting more than their reputation

I challenge you to think of one amateur sleuth who would have solved a mystery if he or she had minded his or her own business. Curiosity definitely solves crimes.

As children, we’re taught the proverb “curiosity killed the cat,” but we’re rarely taught the next line: “satisfaction brought it back.”

Most people only quote the first half, as a warning against poking around or being nosy, but the second half flips the meaning, suggesting that yes, curiosity can get you into trouble, but the answers you find make it worthwhile.

In modern times, curiosity is making a comeback. Corporate trainers use a learning tool called the Mood Elevator, designed by Larry Senn. Different feelings and reactions are assigned individual “floors,” and you’re encouraged to rise up to the “curious” floor from lower-energy floors, such as impatient or fearful.

Nosy at a low energy level is intrusive, but at a high energy level, it is curiosity. Curiosity asks questions without assuming and seeks to understand, not for ammunition.

In real life, being appropriately curious or nosy can help you protect people and can strengthen relationships. It’s what works in a neighborhood watch: preventing problems before they escalate, or noticing when someone hasn’t picked up their mail in a long time.

It makes you a better writer, interviewer, or conversationalist. Isn’t it also a best practice at a cocktail party to ask someone about themselves?

The heart of all of this is really the intention. If you are nosy with good intentions, it provides insight. If you are nosy and judgmental, it is pure gossip, to satisfy your ego rather than to solve a problem or improve a situation.

Yes, I am personally nosy, both as a writer and as a human being, and I have no expectations of changing. I’m going to continue to call a summer neighbor if I suddenly see a light on in their Maine home in the winter. I’m going to keep reaching out to another neighbor if packages start piling up at their mailbox. I’m not rummaging through the mail nor looking in the windows of the winterized, lit house. I’m contacting them out of concern, and I hope my intentions are taken as caring. If not, oh well. I will continue to defend being nosy, both for my own actions and those of my characters, although maybe I’ll switch to using the word “curious.”

                                                                    ***

Allison Keeton’s debut novel is Blaze Orange, Book One in the Midcoast Maine Mystery series. Arctic Green, Book Two, hits the streets (and snowmobile trails) in February 2026. She can be reached at http://www.akeetonbooks.com

Arctic Green, Book Two, Midcoast Maine Mystery series